Gear hobbing, as any cutting process based on the rolling principle, is a signally multi-parametric and complicated gear fabrication method. Although a variety of simulating methods has been proposed, each of them somehow reduces the actual three-dimensional (3D) process to planar models, primarily for simplification reasons. The paper describes an effective and factual simulation of gear hobbing, based on virtual kinematics of solid models representing the cutting tool and the work gear The selected approach, in contrast to former modeling efforts, is primitively realistic, since the produced gear and chips geometry are normal results of successive penetrations and material removal of cutting teeth into a solid cutting piece. The algorithm has been developed and embedded in a commercial CAD environment, by exploiting its modeling and graphics capabilities. To generate the produced chip and gear volumes, the hobbing kinematics is directly applied in one 3D gear gap. The cutting surface of each generating position (successive cutting teeth) formulates a 3D spatial surface, which bounds its penetrating volume into the workpiece. This surface is produced combining the relative rotations and displacements of the two engaged parts (hob and work gear). Such 3D surface "paths" are used to split the subjected volume, creating concurrently the chip and the remaining work gear solid geometries. This algorithm is supported by a universal and modular code as well as by a user friendly graphical interface, for pre- and postprocessing user interactions. The resulting 3D data allow the effective utilization for further research such as prediction of the cutting forces course, tool stresses, and wear development as well as the optimization of the gear hobbing process.
Figures - uploaded by Aristomenis Antoniadis
Author content
All figure content in this area was uploaded by Aristomenis Antoniadis
Content may be subject to copyright.
Discover the world's research
- 20+ million members
- 135+ million publications
- 700k+ research projects
Join for free
Dimitriou Vasilis
Adjunct Professor
Vidakis Nectarios
Associate Professor
Antoniadis Aristomenis
Professor
Technological Educational Institute of Crete,
Romanou 3,
Chania 73133, Greece
Advanced Computer Aided Design
Simulation of Gear Hobbing by
Means of Three-Dimensional
Kinematics Modeling
Gear hobbing, as any cutting process based on the rolling principle, is a signally multi-
parametric and complicated gear fabrication method. Although a variety of simulating
methods has been proposed, each of them somehow reduces the actual three-dimensional
(3D) process to planar models, primarily for simplification reasons. The paper describes
an effective and factual simulation of gear hobbing, based on virtual kinematics of solid
models representing the cutting tool and the work gear. The selected approach, in con-
trast to former modeling efforts, is primitively realistic, since the produced gear and
chips geometry are normal results of successive penetrations and material removal of
cutting teeth into a solid cutting piece. The algorithm has been developed and embedded
in a commercial CAD environment, by exploiting its modeling and graphics capabilities.
To generate the produced chip and gear volumes, the hobbing kinematics is directly
applied in one 3D gear gap. The cutting surface of each generating position (successive
cutting teeth) formulates a 3D spatial surface, which bounds its penetrating volume into
the workpiece. This surface is produced combining the relative rotations and displace-
ments of the two engaged parts (hob and work gear). Such 3D surface "paths" are used
to split the subjected volume, creating concurrently the chip and the remaining work gear
solid geometries. This algorithm is supported by a universal and modular code as well as
by a user friendly graphical interface, for pre- and postprocessing user interactions. The
resulting 3D data allow the effective utilization for further research such as prediction of
the cutting forces course, tool stresses, and wear development as well as the optimization
of the gear hobbing process. 关DOI: 10.1115/1.2738947兴
Keywords: gear hobbing, simulation, 3D-Modeling, CAD
1 Introduction
In most of the demanding torque transmission systems, the key
components are premium well designed and properly fabricated
gears. The gear hobbing process is widely applied for the con-
struction of any external tooth form developed uniformly about a
rotation center. The kinematics principle of the process is based on
three relative motions between the workpiece and the hob tool. To
produce spur or helical gears, the workpiece rotates about its sym-
metry axis with certain constant angular velocity, synchronized
with the relative gear hob rotation. Depending on the hobbing
machine used, the worktable or the hob may travel along the work
axis with the selected feed rate.
Many advances have been made in the development of numeri-
cal and analytical models for the simulation of the gear hobbing
process, aiming to the determination of the undeformed chip ge-
ometry, cutting force components, and tool wear development
关1,2兴. The industrial weight of these three simulation data is asso-
ciated with the optimization of the efficiency per unit cost of the
gear hobbing process. The undeformed chip geometry is an essen-
tial parameter to determine the cutting force components, as well
as to predefine the tool wear development, both of them important
cost related data of the hobbing process 关3兴.
Gear hobbing is nowadays analytically understood, while data
such as chip geometry, cutting force components, mechanical
stresses, and wear performance may be determined with the aid of
consistent software codes 关4–15兴. Despite the research and indus-
trial merit of such programs in the past, a variety of restrictions
and limitations arise, owing to the simplified modeling strategies
that they imply. The basic principle, on which the FRS code was
built in the 1970s, has been the determination of common areas
between one cutting hob tooth profile and the work gear. Hereby,
a two-dimensional 共2D兲 space of a plane determined by the com-
bination of work gear and hob's kinematics was selected as the
calculation region. The accuracy of the chip dimensions approxi-
mated by FRS code depends on various input parameters, such as
number of calculation planes, the discrete interpolation and pro-
jection done on the cutting section planes, and the calculated dis-
continuity of chip thickness. Therefore it is clearly understood that
the resulting plane chip geometry does not represent exactly the
solid geometry of a real chip. As a matter of these facts, transi-
tional thickness variations may not be traced, if they belong to an
intermediate calculation plane of the chosen ones. On the other
hand, any further postprocessing of the calculated chip and gear
geometries requires additional data processing which leads to
supplementary interpolations of the 2D extracted results.
To overcome such modeling insufficiencies, the present re-
search work introduces a new approach, which exploits powerful
modeling capacities of up-to-date CAD software environments.
Hereby, a software module called HOB3D has been developed
from scratch and embedded to an existent commercial CAD sys-
tem. The developed algorithm is built in terms of a computer
code, which is supported by a user friendly graphical interface.
HOB3D provides the extend ability to other cutting processes
based on the same cutting principle. The models output formats
provided from the "parent" CAD system 共.ipt, .sat, .iges, .dxf etc兲
Contributed by the Manufacturing Engineering Division. Manuscript received
August 18, 2006; final manuscript received November 3, 2006. Review conducted by
Dong-Woo Cho.
Journal of Manufacturing Science and Engineering OCTOBER 2007, Vol. 129 /911
Copyright © 2007 by ASME
Downloaded 04 Jan 2008 to 147.27.11.190. Redistribution subject to ASME license or copyright; see http://www.asme.org/terms/Terms_Use.cfm
offer realistic solid parts, chips, and work gear, which can be
easily managed for further investigations individually, or as an
input to other commercial CAD, CAM, or FEA environments.
2 Gear Hobbing Features and Simulation Strategy
Gear hobbing differs significantly from conventional milling,
since its kinematics is governed by the rolling principle between
the hob and the workpiece. To optimize computationally this cut-
ting scheme, the implementation of each geometric feature, kine-
matics and cutting conditions to the developed algorithm, is criti-
cal.
The process problem is basically prescribed from the geometri-
cal characteristics of the gear to be cut, the hob that will be used,
and the involved kinematics between them. As presented at Fig. 1,
the final geometry of a resulting gear is basically described by six
parameters: module 共 m兲 , number of teeth 共z
2
兲, outside diameter
共d
g
兲, helix angle 共 h
a
兲, gear width 共 W兲 , and pressure angle 共 a
n
兲.
The correlation of these parameters automatically yields the mod-
ule 共m 兲 of the hob tool, whereas other tool geometrical parameters
关external diameter 共 d
h
兲, number of columns 共 n
i
兲, number of ori-
gins 共 z
1
兲, axial pitch 共
⑀
兲 and helix angle 共
␥
兲兴, are options to be
chosen. As soon as the geometrical parameters of the two com-
bined parts are set, the kinematics chain has to be initialized. The
helix angle of the hob and the work gear prescribe the setting
angle 共
s
兲 between the parts and the way that their relative mo-
tions shall take place. Three distinct cutting motions are required:
the tool rotation about its axis, the tool axial displacement, and the
workpiece revolution about its axis. By these means, the direction
of the axial feed 共 f
a
兲 prescribes two different hobbing strategies:
the climb 共CL兲 and the up-cut 共 UC 兲. In case of helical gears, two
additional variations exist, the tool helix angle 共
␥
兲 compared to
the helix of the gear 共 h
a
兲. If the direction of the gear helix angle is
identical to the hob helix angle the type of the process is set to
equidirectional 共ED兲, if not to counterdirectional 共CD兲 one.
Focusing on the generation of highly precise geometric models
of undeformed solid chips, as well as on the elimination of any
loss of data occurring from the processing of the geometrical
equations involved with the gear hobbing process, the CAD based
program HOB3D has been introduced. The essential input data
concern the determination of the hob and work gear geometries
and the cutting parameters that take place for the completion of
the simulation process. When the values of the input parameters
are set, the work gear solid geometry is created in the CAD envi-
ronment and one hob tooth rake face profile is mathematically and
visually formed. At the same moment the assembly of the effec-
tive cutting hob teeth 共 N兲 is determined, as presented in Fig. 2.
The kinematics of gear hobbing process is directly applied in one
three-dimensional 共3D兲 tooth gap of the gear, considering the axi-
symetric configuration. Moreover, a 3D surface is formed for ev-
ery generating position 共e.g., successive teeth penetrations兲, com-
bining the allocation of the two involved parts 共hob and work
gear兲 and following a calculated spatial spline as a rail. These 3D
surface "paths" are used to identify the undeformed chip solid
geometry, to split the subjected volume, and to create finally the
chip and the remaining work gear continuous solid geometries.
3 HOB3D Simulation Process
In the developed simulation every rotation and displacement
between the hob and the work gear, for modeling enhancement
reasons, are directly transferred to the hob. By this implementa-
tion a global coordinate system that is placed on the center of the
upper gear base is always fixed and provides a steady reference
point to monitor the traveling hob.
3.1 Mathematical Formulation. Without any loss of gener-
ality, the hob is considered to have one and only tooth 共numbered-
named "tooth 0"兲. The identification vector 共
v
0
兲 of "tooth 0" has
its origin 共 C
H
兲 on the Y
h
axis of the hob and its end at the middle
of the rake face, forming a module that equals to 兩
v
0
兩 = d
h
/2. The
identification vector determines the direction of the Z
h
axis of the
hob coordination system 共X
h
Y
h
Z
h
兲 and is initially placed as an
offset of the global Z axis, set at a vertical distance L
1
from the
origin of the XYZ global system. The right part of Fig. 3 illustrates
how the parameter L
1
determines the region where the cutting
starts. Once the simulation parameters are settled, the work gear
solid model is generated and the assembly of the effective cutting
hob teeth is enabled. The moment that the gear hobbing simula-
tion starts is considered as time zero. At this time 共t =0 兲 the planes
YZ and Y
h
Z
h
are parallel and their horizontal distance, steady for
the whole simulation period, is set to value L
2
= d
h
/2+d
g
/2−t.
Distance L
2
practically determines the cutting depth, user defined
as an input parameter. To determine the setting angle 共
s
兲, the
X
h
Y
h
Z
h
hob coordinate system is rotated about the X
h
axis, so that
the simulation process becomes completely prescribed. Using the
spatial vector
v
0
, it is easy to compute the identification vectors
v
i
of effective teeth N, with −k 艋 i 艋 n and N = n + k +1, k , n 苸 Z
+
tak-
ing into account the hob geometrical input parameters, relative to
v
0
.
In addition, the independent parameter
1
counts the rotational
angle of hob tool about its axis Y
h
during the cutting simulation.
Fig. 1 Intrinsic principles and features of gear hobbing process
912 / Vol. 129, OCTOBER 2007 Transactions of the ASME
Downloaded 04 Jan 2008 to 147.27.11.190. Redistribution subject to ASME license or copyright; see http://www.asme.org/terms/Terms_Use.cfm
Since
2
declares the rotational angle of hob tool about the work
gear and f
a
the axial feed of hob, their values are dependent on
1
and can be determined according to this angle values 共see also the
left part of Fig. 3兲.
As mentioned before, the forward kinematics of each of the N
effective cutting hob teeth occur in one gear tooth space 共gap兲.
Hereby, after the determination of
v
0
共tooth 0兲 and considering
that
v
−k
is relative to
v
0
the forward kinematics are first applied to
v
−k
and afterwards to the following vectors
v
i
, simulating pre-
cisely the real manufacturing process. For the determination of the
involved hob-gear kinematics, the following transformational ma-
trices R
x, a
共rotation about X axis with
␣
angle兲, R
y,
共rotation
about Y axis with
angle兲, R
z,
共rotation about Z axis with
angle兲, are used:
R
x,
␣
=
冤
10 0
0
cos共
␣
兲 − sin共
␣
兲
0
sin共
␣
兲 cos共
␣
兲
冥
,
R
y,
=
冤
cos共
兲
0
sin共
兲
010
− sin共
兲
0
cos共
兲
冥
,
R
z,
=
冤
cos共
兲 − sin共
兲
0
sin共
兲 cos共
兲
0
001
冥
共1 兲
Fig. 2 The flow chart of the developed HOB3D gear hobbing simulation code
Fig. 3 Gear hobbing simulation kinematics scheme
Journal of Manufacturing Science and Engineering OCTOBER 2007, Vol. 129 / 913
Downloaded 04 Jan 2008 to 147.27.11.190. Redistribution subject to ASME license or copyright; see http://www.asme.org/terms/Terms_Use.cfm
In case of simulating helical gears fabrication, a differential
angular amount is put on the rotating system of the gear, in order
to increase or decrease the angular velocity of the rotating work-
piece, ensuring the proper mechanical functionality 共meshing兲 of
the hob-cutting and gear-cut angles. Depending on the hobbing
type process a new angular parameter 共d
兲 has to be inserted to
the whole kinematical chain for the acceleration or deceleration of
2
. The calculation of the parametrical value of d
is taking place
on the pitch circle as presented in Fig. 4.
3.2 Exploitation of Modeling and Graphical Features of
the CAD Environment. Using the kinematics scheme described
in the previous paragraph, a spatial spline path is created inside
the CAD system, by interpolating the points generated from the
transformation of each
v
i
vector of each cutting hob tooth relative
to the hob axis Y
h
共using
1
兲 and the global Z axis 共using
2
兲,as
well as the displacement f
a
共see Fig. 5共a兲兲. Thereby, the unit vec-
tors 共 C
H
n
1
兲
i
and 共 C
H
n
2
兲
i
, described in Fig. 5共b兲, are rotated and
shifted for the creation of a plane properly positioned into the 3D
space, for every revolving position of a certain cutting tooth i. The
profile of the cutting hob tooth is formed on the 2D space that is
created on its rake plane. This process takes place for every re-
volving position, as graphically illustrated in Fig. 5共c兲.
By shifting these open cutting hob tooth profiles and using the
spatial spline path as a rail, a 3D surface path is constructed in one
gear tooth space. This path represents the generating position of
"tooth i". With the aid of this surface path, the solid geometry of
a chip is identified for every generating position, using the bool-
ean operations and the graphics capabilities of the CAD environ-
ment, as presented in Fig. 6共a兲. The chip geometry is restricted by
the external volume of the instantly formed working gear gap,
bounded outside the created surface. The identified solid geometry
is then subtracted from the workpiece, as it is presented in Fig.
6共b兲, generating the continuous 3D geometries of the chip and the
remaining work gear.
Bearing in mind the solid outputs form of the simulation pro-
cess, their direct postprocessing is primitively enabled. Fig. 6共b兲
illustrates the chip solid geometry that is produced during a cer-
tain revolving position, whereas the detected maximum chip
thickness is presented in detail A.
To save computational time and resources, in every generating
position of each effective cutting tooth i, the overall rotation of the
hob about its symmetry axis Y
h
is restricted 共 0° 艋
1
艋 180° 兲 .In
this way, during the entire simulation process, only motions that
affect the resulting solid geometries are taking place, without any
influence to the process sufficiency. After the completion of one
work cycle, i.e., the termination of every spatial surface path and
the subtraction of the chip solid geometries, the produced gear gap
is finally generated. Fig. 7 illustrates a cross section 共detail A兲 of
Fig. 4 Determination of d
angle in case of helical gear cutting simulation
Fig. 5 Generation principle of hob tooth path for its generating position
914 / Vol. 129, OCTOBER 2007 Transactions of the ASME
Downloaded 04 Jan 2008 to 147.27.11.190. Redistribution subject to ASME license or copyright; see http://www.asme.org/terms/Terms_Use.cfm
the generated gear gap, formed by the collective work of every
generating position. As can be seen in Fig. 7共c兲, the remaining
gear solid geometry holds complete geometrical information, both
for the removed and the remaining "material."
4 Generation and Storage of Solid Chip Entities
The main data-entry window of the HOB3D graphical interface
is presented in Fig. 8. The specific data entry includes the sections
of hob and work gear data, as well as selected cutting conditions
and the user defined postdata. An up-cut 共 UC 兲 case for the simu-
lation of a spur gear fabrication is used, in order to demonstrate
the program functionality.
The input data described at the previous sections are manually
inserted in their corresponding input boxes. The highlighted input
boxes, also recognized by an asterisk, refer to modeling param-
eters, which are automatically calculated and proposed by
HOB3D algorithm, offering simultaneously the possibility to be
user defined. The picture at the middle bottom part of the input
data window visualizes the strategy selected for each simulating
scenario. As can be observed at the output section, the program
uses a working folder, set by the user, to save in proper formats
the chosen outputs. The simulation parameters can also be saved
and reopened by selecting appropriate fields, while a simulation
report comprising the user selected output results may be option-
ally created after the completion of the simulation process.
Figure 9 illustrates the resulted solid geometry of the chip pro-
duced from the generating position gp= −4 of the above-presented
test case. The normally continuous chip solid geometry, for visu-
alization purposes, has been sliced in each of the 91 assigned
revolving positions belonging to the kinematics transformations of
hob tooth "−4." The intersecting planes of the revolving positions
along with the chip geometry are illustrated in the left part of Fig.
9, while the sliced solid geometry chip cross sections, on the same
revolving positions, are presented in the middle part. It is evident
that every revolving position generates the same profile on two
successive sliced parts of the chip. This is the reason why each
sliced part has the name of two successive generating positions.
The maximum thicknesses of each cross section 共h
max
兲 are iden-
tified, as shown at the three inserted details their development is
described in the right diagram of Fig. 9.
The output chip solid geometries at 15 characteristic generating
positions of two different test cases, UC and CL, produced by the
activation of the HOB3D code, are presented in the left and right
parts of Fig. 10, respectively. Except for the direction of the axial
feed f
a
all other input data are identical, for both examined cases.
Examining each of the resulting chips, it is obvious that so many
of the extreme geometrical changes of the chip shapes are suffi-
ciently determined, even if the generated chip solid is parted from
more than one domain.
The resulting 3D solid geometries for both gear gaps, generated
for the same presented cases, are ideal to verify and validate the
proposed algorithm. Since the gear gaps are generated by subtract-
ing the solid volume of each chip from the initially cylindrical
work gear solid geometry, every cross section of them, passing
parallel to the XY plane, offers a polyline which corresponds to
the calculated profile 共see Fig. 7 right part兲. These two produced
gap profiles are compared to the standard ones introduced by Petri
关16兴 and DIN 3972 关17兴, as presented in the left part of Fig. 11. To
determine the calculated profile deviation, the dichotomy between
them and the nominal profile is calculated and the occurring error
Fig. 6 Solid chip geometry identification process
Fig. 7 Visual gear gap generation by HOB3D
Journal of Manufacturing Science and Engineering OCTOBER 2007, Vol. 129 / 915
Downloaded 04 Jan 2008 to 147.27.11.190. Redistribution subject to ASME license or copyright; see http://www.asme.org/terms/Terms_Use.cfm
is measured at its direction, as presented in detail A of Fig. 11. The
calculated error of each test case is plotted to the graphs presented
at the right part of Fig. 11, illustrating a mean error less than
10
m for the working depth of produced gears, for the UC and
CL cases, respectively. Such negligible deviations satisfy the com-
putational accuracy expectations, and verify the sufficiency of the
developed code.
5 Conclusions
The paper illustrated an advanced and validated simulation
method for gear hobbing process, based on a commercial CAD
environment. In contrast to former research attempts, in the
present investigations, the kinematics of gear hobbing is directly
applied in one tooth 3D space by the construction of spatial sur-
face paths, for every generating position. The kinematics involves
the rotations and displacements of the two rolling parts 共hob and
work gear兲 for every possible manufacturing case of gear hobbing
process. These 3D surface "paths" are used to divide the subjected
volume and directly create the chip and the remaining work gear
continuous solid geometries. The algorithm is supported by a
computer code with the aid of a user friendly graphical interface.
Considering the quality and the format of the resulting solid ge-
ometries, it is implicit that further manipulation and postprocess-
ing of them is effortlessly achievable, without further postprocess-
ing. The confirmation of the validity and accuracy of the proposed
method has been accomplished by comparing the produced gear
Fig. 8 HOB3D data-entry window
Fig. 9 Solid chip formation at specific generating position in gear hobbing
916 / Vol. 129, OCTOBER 2007 Transactions of the ASME
Downloaded 04 Jan 2008 to 147.27.11.190. Redistribution subject to ASME license or copyright; see http://www.asme.org/terms/Terms_Use.cfm
gap profile with theoretical ones, expressing a faultless agreement
between them. The results of the present work hold significant
industrial and research interest, including the accurate prediction
of dynamic behavior and tool wear development in gear hobbing
procedure.
Nomenclature
CL ⫽ climb hobbing
UC ⫽ up-cut hobbing
ED ⫽ equidirectional hobbing
CD ⫽ counterdirectional hobbing
GP ⫽ generating position
RP ⫽ revolving position
f
a
⫽ axial feed 共mm/wrev兲
t ⫽ cutting depth 共 mm 兲
v
⫽ cutting speed 共 m/min 兲
m ⫽ work gear and hob tool module 共 mm 兲
n
i
⫽ number of hob columns
z
1
⫽ number of hob origins
z
2
⫽ number of work gear teeth
d
g
⫽ external work gear diameter 共 mm 兲
h
a
⫽ gear helix angle 共°兲
Fig. 11 Algorithm verification as with the aid of the calculated gear gap profile and the nomi-
nal theoretical one
Fig. 10 Typical solid chips at up-cut and climb hobbing
Journal of Manufacturing Science and Engineering OCTOBER 2007, Vol. 129 / 917
Downloaded 04 Jan 2008 to 147.27.11.190. Redistribution subject to ASME license or copyright; see http://www.asme.org/terms/Terms_Use.cfm
References
关1兴 Klocke, F., and Klein, A., 2006, "Tool Life and Productivity Improvement
Through Cutting Parameter Setting and Tool Design in Dry High-Speed Bevel
Gear Tooth Cutting," Gear Technol., May/June, pp. 40–48.
关2兴 Rech, J., 2006, "Influence of Cutting Edge Preparation on the Wear Resistance
in High Speed Dry Gear Hobbing," Wear, 261共 5–6兲, pp. 505–512.
关3兴 Rech, J., Djouadi, M. A., and Picot, J., 2001, "Wear Resistance of Coatings in
High Speed Gear Hobbing," Wear, 250, pp. 45–53.
关4兴 Sulzer, G., 1974, "Leistungssteigerung bei der Zylinderradherstellung durch
genaue Erfassung der Zerspankinematik," dissertation, TH Aachen, Aachen,
Germany.
关5兴 Gutman, P., 1988, "Zerspankraftberechnung beim Waelzfraesen," dissertation,
TH Aachen, Aachen, Germany.
关6兴 Venohr, G., 1985, "Beitrag zum Einsatz von hartmetall Werkzeugen beim
Waelzfraesen," dissertation, TH Aachen, Aachen, Germany.
关7兴 Joppa, K., 1977, "Leistungssteigerung beim Waelzfraesen mit Schnellarbeitss-
tahl durch Analyse, Beurteilung und Beinflussung des Zerspanprozesses," dis-
sertation, TH Aachen, Aachen, Germany.
关8兴 Tondorf, J., 1978, "Erhoehung der Fertigungsgenauigkeit beim Waelzfraesen
durch Systematische Vermeidung von Aufbauschneiden," dissertation, TH
Aachen, Aachen, Germany.
关9兴 Antoniadis, A., 1988, "Determination of the Impact Tool Stresses During Gear
Hobbing and Determination of Cutting Forces During Hobbing of Hardened
Gears," dissertation, Aristoteles University of Thessaloniki, Thessaloniki,
Greece.
关10兴 Antoniadis, A., Vidakis, N., and Bilalis, N., 2002, "Failure Fracture Investiga-
tion of Cemented Carbide Tools Used in Gear Hobbing—Part I: FEM Model-
ing of Fly Hobbing and Computational Interpretation of Experimental Re-
sults," ASME J. Manuf. Sci. Eng., 124共4兲 , pp. 784–791.
关11 兴 Antoniadis, A., Vidakis, N., and Bilalis, N., 2002, "Failure Fracture Investiga-
tion of Cemented Carbide Tools Used in Gear Hobbing—Part II: The Effect of
Cutting Parameters on the Level of Tool Stresses—A Quantitive Parametric
Analysis," ASME J. Manuf. Sci. Eng., 124共4兲 , pp. 792–798.
关12兴 Sinkevicius, V., 1999, "Simulation of Gear Hobbing Geometrical Size," Kau-
nas University of Technology Journal "Mechanika," 5共 20兲, pp. 34–39.
关13兴 Sinkevicius, V., 2001, "Simulation of Gear Hobbing Forces," Kaunas Univer-
sity of Technology Journal "Mechanika," 2共 28兲, pp. 58–63.
关14兴 Komori, M., Sumi, M., and Kubo, A., 2004, "Method of Preventing Cutting
Edge Failure of Hob due to Chip Crush," JSME Int. J., Ser. C, 47共
4兲 , pp.
1140–1148.
关15兴 Komori, M., Sumi, M., and Kubo, A., 2004, "Simulation of Hobbing for
Analysis of Cutting Edge Failure due to Chip Crush," Gear Technol., Sept./
Oct., pp. 64–69.
关16兴 Petri, H., 1975, "Zahnhuß–Analyse bei außenverzahnten Evolventenstirnraed-
ern : Teil III Berechnung," Antriebstechnik, 14共5兲 , pp. 289–297.
关17兴 DIN 3972, 1992, Bezugsprofile von Verzahnwerkzeugen fuer Evolventen-
Verzahnungen nach DIN 867, Taschenbuch 106, Beuth Verlag.
918 / Vol. 129, OCTOBER 2007 Transactions of the ASME
Downloaded 04 Jan 2008 to 147.27.11.190. Redistribution subject to ASME license or copyright; see http://www.asme.org/terms/Terms_Use.cfm
... The result of their work is the advanced computer aided model that interconnects of the cutting section parameters with certain processes and initial parameters and allows you to evaluate the effectiveness of the gear machining process according to some criterion. So, in the works [1,2] the influence of cut sections of the hob on the force of cutting is established. The works [2,3,4] are dedicated to the study of the influence of section parameters on the stresses in the tool, the development of wear, stability and durability of hob mills. ...
... Currently, a sufficiently large number of studies using various methods of modeling the dynamics of the spatial hobbing process is known [1][2][3][4]7]. Some of these approaches allow us to investigate the dynamic stability of tooth milling at each point of the machining path with fixed geometrical parameters of the cutting zone. Threedimensional diagram of the machining stability, where as an additional axis is used the coordinate along the trajectory of the tool, is proposes to construct in the works [2,3]. ...
... The simulation model allows us to estimate the level of vibrations, the shape deviation and the surface quality of the machined part, as well as the magnitude of the cutting forces for various combinations of process parameters. Analysis of examples of the machining processes modeling during gear hobbing allowed to establish that a full dynamic analysis of the machining process should include the following components of the model: a model of the tool dynamics; cutting forces model; model of the formation of new surfaces; model of the analysis of errors in the profile of the machined wheel [1,2,3]. ...
- Ihor Hrytsay
-
The results of a comprehensive study of the hobbing process dynamic parameters based on interrelated models are given in the article. The elastic cutting system is the first component of this system. Parameters of the elastic system are determined based on the simulation of the thickness and sectional area of the cutting cross-sections and by the analysis of the transient process of forming the cutting force in the system Deform 3D. The second component of the model includes the description of oscillating processes in the circuits of the hob and the workpiece of the toothed wheel. The method of experimental determination of the dynamic parameters of this system and the determination of its amplitude-phase frequency response is described. The equivalent elastic system and the own frequencies of the most powerful oscillations of the machine elements are analyzed. The behavior of the closed system of the machine with the cutting process under the influence of changing the cutting parameters (feed and cutting speed) is simulated in the Simulink MATLAB system. On the basis of this, the optimal cutting modes and parameters according to the criterion of ensuring the required stability of the tool machine during the hobbing can be appointed.
... Previously, the calculation methods of undeformed chip thickness in gear machining mainly include 3D CAD method and analytical method. Dimitriou et al. [9,10] and Tapoglou et al. [11] established the CAD-based simulation method for calculating the undeformed chip thickness in hobbing, and based on the method the force prediction software Hob3D [12] was obtained, but this method would give an error in the calculation of undeformed chip thickness. Brecher et al. [13] obtained a simple method to calculate the maximum chip thickness, which brought processing and geometric parameters into consideration. ...
- Xiankang Tang
-
- Zijian Zhang
The cutting forces generated in gear milling are different from the cutting forces generated in milling and turning, due to the influence of the three-dimensional undeformed chip and penetration curve. To establish the cutting forces model to predict the cutting forces for gear milling, a mechanistic model considering three-dimensional undeformed chip thickness, penetration curve, and working angles is presented. In this paper, the calculation method for three-dimensional undeformed chip thickness is provided. In addition, the formula of penetration curve, a space curve of intersection of the sweep volume formed by the cutting edge and the outside cylinders of the workpiece, is obtained, which determines the machining zone. Moreover, the vector of resultant cutting speed is determined by vector analysis, on the basis of which, the working normal rake angle and working cutting edge inclination angle are determined. Furthermore, a gear milling cutter was used to carry out experiments to validate the cutting force model. The experimental results correlate in the predicted results and the errors of peak are around 20% in x-axis and y-axis. The main findings drawn from the experiments and simulations are that the peak of cutting forces of the down milling is higher than the peak of cutting forces of the up milling especially in the x-direction, due to the influence of the three-dimensional undeformed chip thickness.
... In generative gear machining, however, the complexity of the kinematics, as well as the tool and part geometries, render prior derivation of an analytical CWE expression very difficult. Thus, in gear hobbing, several studies have instead relied on a solid modeling engine to resolve the CWE [4,5]. While this method provides the highest accuracy, the computations become increasingly time-consuming with the large number of 3D analytical geometry entities that must be constructed and updated to keep track of each cut surface feature. ...
This paper presents a tri-dexel geometric engine integrated simulation model for the gear hobbing operation. The process kinematics are modeled and validated using CNC signals from a Liebherr LC500 hobbing machine. Workpiece geometry updating and cutter-workpiece engagement (CWE) calculations are efficiently realized in the tri-dexel engine. 3D force contributions at discretized nodes along the hob's cutting edges are computed considering the localized principal cutting directions, and rake and inclination angles. To measure cutting forces, a rotary dynamometer is successfully adapted and used alongside a Kalman filter to compensate for structural dynamics. The predicted forces agree well with their experimental counterparts.
... For the gear process in particular, many works were also conducted with unique gear generating kinematics: Pierce McCloskey et al. [29] proposed an uncut chip model for gear skiving process using a commercial multi-dexel solid modeling engine, ModuleWorks, and further established a cutting force estimation model based on the orthogonal cutting coefficient model; Thomas Bergs [30] put forward a cutting force prediction model for gear honing based on kinematic simulation for honing and velocity distribution in gear flank; Tomokazu Tachikawa et al. [31] developed an analytical method for cutting force prediction in gear skiving, simplifying the force as the sum of vectors that represent direction and depth of cutting edge penetration to the gear; Kaan Erkorkmaz, et al. [32] presented a discrete modeling method for un-deformed chip geometry and cutting force using multi-dexel volume representation to extract cutter-workpiece engagement for gear shaping; D. Bouzakis [33] gave a review of different gear processes, involving generating kinematics simulation, un-deformed chip calculation, cutting force modeling and tool wear calculation; Nikolaos T. et al. [34], Vasilis D. [35] and Dimitriou V. [36] investigated gear hobbing process, focusing on un-deformed chip geometry and cutting force prediction through the HoB3D Ò platform developed; Andrew Katz et al. [37,38] discussed virtual gear shaping modeling, addressing kinematics, cutter workpiece engagement, cutting force and elastic deformation; Aistomenis Antoniadis et al. [39,40] proposed a 3D based modeling method for un-deformed chip and cutting force in commercial platform for gear skiving; Mohsen Habibi [41,42] came up with a semi-analytical approach to un-deformed cutting chip and cutting force prediction for spiral bevel gear through converting the process into many infinitesimal oblique cuts along cutting edges of the outside and inside blades. ...
For an efficient and precise machining of spiral gear, the special face-milling process for spiral bevel gear is developed and widely used, exhibiting great difference from the general milling process in cutting machine, cutter and cutting kinematics. The un-deformed chip geometry, cutting force model and regenerating mechanism are hence complexly different, bringing great challenge to the modeling of cutting dynamics. In this regard, no relevant work can be found at present. To overcome this problem, through fully investigating the cutting force regenerating mechanism under complicated cutting kinematics, this paper first develops an analytical cutting force prediction model by classifying the chip geometry into 6 cases, and then a simplified dynamic chip model by assuming the chip geometry cases unchanged and ignoring edge alteration. On such basis, the model for prediction of the cutting dynamics and the chatter stability are developed and validated. Besides, the 3D stability lobe for face-milling of spiral bevel gear is presented and the cutting system tends to be stable with high cutter gear ratio and cutting speed.
... Moreover, the tool was developed with Visual Lisp and is particularly helpful for rotational parts. Dimitriou et al. [7] described an effective simulation of gear hobbing, based on virtual kinematics of CAD models. The algorithm was developed and embedded in a commercial CAD software by using the modern programming resources available. ...
The resources of modern Finite Element Analysis (FEA) software provide engineers with powerful mechanisms that can be used to investigate numerous machining processes with satisfying results. Nevertheless, the success of a simulation, especially in three dimensions, relies heavily on the accuracy of the cutting tool models that are implemented in the analyses. With this in mind, the present paper presents an application developed via Computer-Aided Design (CAD) programming that enables the automated design of accurate cutting tool models that can be used in 3D turning simulations. The presented application was developed with the aid of the programming resources of a commercially available CAD system. Moreover, the parametric design methodology was employed in order to design the tools according to the appropriate standards. Concluding, a sample tool model was tested by performing a number of machining simulations based on typical cutting parameters. The yielded results were then compared to experimental values of the generated machining force components for validation. The findings of the study prove the functionality of the tool models since a high level of agreement occurred between the acquired numerical results and the experimental ones.
... used for roughing and finishing [2] A tool that is most commonly used in the modern gear wheel machining industry is the monolithic modular hob with a very large number of teeth on its perimeter (leaf-type hob) ( Fig. 1)-During machining, the tool is moved (shifted) relative to the gear wheel being machined. Gear wheel hobs are ranked among the tools of the most complex geometry [3,4,5,6] and are used for cutting spur gears and helical gears within a whole range of modules, from 0.25 to 25 mm [7,8]. Machining is conducted on specialised hobbing machine tools. ...
In this report, an approach is presented how a geometric penetration calculation can be combined with FE simulations to a multiscale model, which allows an efficient determination of the thermomechanical load in gear hobbing. FE simulations of the linear-orthogonal cut are used to derive approximate equations for calculating the cutting force and the rake face temperature. The hobbing process is then simulated with a geometric penetration calculation and uncut chip geometries are determined for each generating position. The uncut chip geometries serve as input variables for the derived equations, which are solved at each point of the cutting edge for each generating position. The cutting force is scaled according to the established procedure of discrete addition of the forces along the cutting edge over all individual cross-section elements. For the calculation of the temperature, an approach is presented how to consider a variable chip thickness profile. Based on this, the temperature distribution on the rake face is calculated. The model is verified on the one hand by cutting force measurements in machining trials and on the other hand by an FE simulation of a full engagement of a hob tooth.
- S V Lukina
- Sergey Ivannikov
- Margarita Krutyakova
The article suggests a new method of controlling the precision of geometrically complex mould making, improving the quality of machine tool systems at the preproduction engineering stage. The method is based upon a developed set of predictive simulation tools, consisting of a total of mathematical, virtual, and simulation models, describing the process of geometrically complex mould making. A conceptual solution for the problem of control on geometrically complex mould making combines two methods. The first is the analytical generation of various structural & geometrical combinations of the elements of industrial process systems providing geometrically complex mould making. The second method implies the geometrical realization of a spatial virtual simulation model for geometrically complex mould making. The mathematical simulation of geometrically complex mould making is implemented for a free spatial camming surface represented by a total of a set of guideways and a set of generatrices. The error of metal treatment of an arbitrary surface point is defined by the difference of the radius vectors of the actual and set positions of the tool contact point and the workpiece treated surface. The control over the precision of geometrically complex mould making is implemented by means of the conditions, providing the location of a resulting error vector inside a computational region of the machine operation area by searching for an optimal combination of industrial, structural and operation parameters at the stage of project design of the elements of the industrial process metal treatment system.
- F. Klocke
- A. Klein
The introduction of carbide tools and hard coatings has led to a quantum leap in material removal rates and tool life in manufacturing automotive-sized bevel and hypoid gears, as the tools and coatings have in other areas of machining technology (Refs. 1-6). Further benefits of the new techology are the ability to abandon the use of coolant and the improvement of quality, which partly goes back also to advancements in the machine tool technology and the implementation of quality loops in manufacturing (Ref. 3-4 and 7-13). However, the number of influential factors on manufacturing cost per piece is high, and an in-depth process analysis and understanding has not yet been established in many areas. Yet this fundamental knowledge is required to show the right direction for further enhancements of economic efficiency and productivity, since thorough process development is difficult to conduct during and after the start of production in an industrial environment (Ref. 13). Therefore, thorough machining investigations are conducted at WZL within the scope of an AiF research project (13713 N/1) on high speed bevel gear machining. This article presents some of the findings of cutting investigations at WZL in which the correlation of cutting parameters, cutting materials, tool geometry and tool life have been determined. Finally, the idea for a new WZL face milling tool concept, which has some significant theoretical advantages over state-of-the-art tool systems, is presented.
- Masaharu Komori
- Masaoki Sumi
- Aizoh Kubo
There are great advantages in dry hobbing not only for friendliness on the environment, but also for increasing productivity and for decreasing manufacturing cost. Dry hobbing, however, often causes failures of cutting edge of hob or problems about the surface quality of tooth flank of manufactured gear, which have not been of problem in case of hobbing with cutting oil. Pinching and crushing of generated chips between cutting edge of hob and tooth flank of work gear is considered to be a major cause for those problems. In this report, a calculating method of trace of each cutting edge of hob relative to work gear is compiled to simulate the clearance between cutting edge of hob and tooth flank of work gear. The thickness and form of generated chip and its movement on rake surface of hob tooth during hobbing process can be clarified by consulting the result of this simulation. Probability of pinching of chips between cutting edges of hob and tooth flank can be evaluated by dealing with the relation among the position and width of clearance, chip thickness and direction of chip movement, which contributes to successful dry hobbing.
Gear hobbing remains a cutting technology where high speed steels continue to find wide applications in modern manufacturing practice. The improvements in hobbing tool design are problematic due to the very long duration of wear tests. The application of an analogy process called 'fly hobbing' has been developed on a five-axes milling machine so as to improve the productivity of the investigations. This process has been used to investigate the influence of the cutting edge preparation on the wear resistance of gear hobs made of PM-HSS in the context of dry high-speed manufacturing. An original edge preparation procedure, based on the abrasive flow machining technology, has revealed a great improvement of the tool life. (c) 2005 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Gear Hobbing is a complex gear manufacturing method, possessing great industrial significance. The convoluted geometry of the cutting tools brings on modeling problems and is the main reason for the almost exclusive application of HSS as cutting material. However despite its complicated kinematics, gear hobbing is sufficiently described by well-established software tools, which were presented in the first part of the present paper. Experimental investigations exhibited the cutting performance of cemented carbide cutting teeth, which were expected to be potential alternatives for massive hob production. In these cutting experiments, hardmetal tools exhibited in several cases early and unexpected brittle failures, which were interpreted by the FRSFEM model in the first part of the paper. This analysis indicated that the occurring dynamic stresses are the reason for the observed fatigue failures on the cemented carbide tools. The occurring stresses are highly dependent on the selection of cutting parameters and on the tool geometry. Therefore, the proper selection of the cutting data may prevent the early tool failures, as the dominant parameters for tool wear allowing it to be worn out by the conventional abrasive mechanisms. Thus, the doubtless dominance of cemented carbide over the HSS tools, may be rendered. The present work illustrates a parametric analysis, which describes quantitatively the effect of various cutting and technological parameters on the stress level occurring in gear hobbing, with cemented carbide cutting teeth. Hereby, the optimization of the tool life is enabled, allowing the maximum exploitation of modern gear hobbing machine tools. Optimized gear hobbing with cemented carbide tools may be used, in order to introduce higher cutting speeds in massive gear production.
Gear hobbing is a highly utilized flexible manufacturing process for massive production of external gears. However the complex geometry of cutting hobs is responsible for the almost exclusive utilization of high-speed steel (HSS) as cutting tool material. The limited cutting performance of HSS, even coated HSS, restricts the application of high cutting speeds and restricts the full exploitation of modem CNC hobbing machine tools. The application of cemented carbide tools was considered as a potential alternative to modem production requirements. In former investigations an experimental variation of gear hobbing, the so-called fly hobbing was applied, in order to specify the cutting performance of cemented carbide tools in gear production. These thorough experiments indicated that cracks, which were not expected, might occur in specific cutting cases, leading to the early failure of the entire cutting tool. In order to interpret computationally the reasons for these failures, an FEM simulation of the cutting process was developed, supported by advanced software tools able to determine the chip formation and the cutting forces during gear bobbing. The computational results explain sufficiently the failure mechanisms and they are quite in line with the experimental findings. The first part of this paper applies the verified parametric FEM model for various cutting cases, indicating the most risky cutting teeth with respect to their fatigue danger In a step forward, the second part of the paper illustrates the effect of various technological and geometric parameters to the expected tool,life. Therefore, the optimization of the cutting process is enabled, through the proper selection of cutting parameters, which can eliminate the failure danger of cemented carbide cutting tools, thus achieving satisfactory cost effectiveness.
-
- Mohamed A Djouadi
- J Picot
Coating technology is one means of achieving a crucial enhancement in tool performance, especially in hobs that were among the first tools to be coated on a large scale. Nevertheless only few detailed analysis of wear mechanism have been done on field machines. The bifunctional coatings (combination of a tough, hard and refractory coating and of a self lubricating coating possessing a good thermochemical and abrasion resistance but a lower hardness) are very interesting since it is difficult to get a simple coating showing all these characteristics. The use of bilayer coatings raises several problems especially for dry and high speed cutting. Therefore, in order to investigate the behaviour of these bifunctional coatings, hobs have been coated by physical vapour deposition (PVD) methods. After the elaboration of a procedure for hobs testing, field tests have been performed. Results of tool life tests and investigations on tool wear mechanisms for different coated hobs are presented and discussed. The interesting performance in high speed gear hobbing of sintered high speed steel (HSS) hobs (ASP2052) combined with a (Ti,Al)N+MoS2 coating is particularly underlined.
- Johannes. Tondorf
Thesis (doctoral)--Rheinisch-Westfälische Technische Hochschule Aachen, 1978.
- Masaharu Komori
- Masaoki Sumi
- Aizoh Kubo
Dry hobbing has great advantages such as its environmental friendliness and its ability to reduce manufacturing cost. Dry hobbing, however, often causes failures of the cutting edge of a hob or problems on the surface quality of the tooth flank of a manufactured gear. The pinching and crushing of generated chips between the cutting edge of a hob and the tooth flank of a work gear is considered to be a major cause of such problems. A simulation method of cutting using a hob was reported. In this report, the simulation is applied to solving the industrial problems of dry hobbing. The simulation clarifies the mechanism of cutting edge failures. The ``distance of single-edge cutting'' of a hob tooth is proposed to be an index of pinching and crushing of chips. Factors influencing this index are investigated and fundamental countermeasures against pinching and crushing are shown. This method has been applied to solving problems in the mass production of automotive gears, and good results were obtained.
Bezugsprofile von Verzahnwerkzeugen fuer Evolventen-Verzahnungen nach DIN
͓17͔ DIN 3972, 1992, Bezugsprofile von Verzahnwerkzeugen fuer Evolventen-Verzahnungen nach DIN 867, Taschenbuch 106, Beuth Verlag.
Simulation of Gear Hobbing Geometrical Size
- Sinkevicius
Sinkevicius, V., 1999, "Simulation of Gear Hobbing Geometrical Size," Kaunas University of Technology Journal "Mechanika," 5͑20͒, pp. 34-39.
Source: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/245368612_Advanced_Computer_Aided_Design_Simulation_of_Gear_Hobbing_by_Means_of_Three-Dimensional_Kinematics_Modeling
Posted by: twilacantonerie.blogspot.com